This is an unfinished center--nothing is stitched except the green stems to the bases of the flowers. But I'm not sure they're really improv-style flowers. What do you think? The improv flowers I've seen on quilts seem to be more static and stylized than these.
Notes on unfinished parts of the center.
- The white in the center at the base of the flower is white paper pinned as a place-holder for either another shade of green or some other color. (What shade of green or what color?) Or don't add them at all?
- The little dots under one side of each of the flowers--brown paper affixed with halved adhesive circles--were in my original drawing except on both sides of the stem. They don't have any significance, but I like the idea even though they're more decorative than anything else. But then there's the color....
- The vase shape and size are yet to be determined (if I continue with these flowers). Wider? Shorter? Color?
I really like the flowers. In fact, I love the flowers. I'm just uncertain about their being at the center of an improv quilt. I don't know what's coming next for the first border and subsequent borders so I don't know how that will impact this center.
If I continue with these flowers, to your eye what looks settled and what doesn't? What's missing? Do they need leaves? Do they need rearranged? What about the empty spaces on either side of the container that holds the stems? Too bare? (I know I can always add later.) Should there not be a container and, if so, what color? Is the background too big? Are the flowers too big? Are there too many, or too few, flowers? Would one be enough? (You can see my first idea for a layout at this post if you scroll down a little.) I'm really out of my element with making a quilt guided by someone else but I'm also finding the challenge worthwhile.
Here are close-ups of the individual flowers, left, center, then right. I do really love them and if I don't use them for this quilt they will definitely appear in some future quilt.
As I understand it, improv is both a style of quilt and a process for making a quilt. Does it matter in the end whether a quilt looks like the usual improv quilts we see? It probably matters more that it looks like a finished, complete quilt, and that all the parts and pieces belong where they are. Perhaps process is more important than style?
I would love to hear your thoughts and opinions about these flowers as a center block for Audrey's Bramble Blooms 1 improv quilt-along. Even if comments are somewhat critical or negative but kindly stated, I'd like to read them.
Big thanks to Audrey of Quilty Folk who is hosting this quilt-along. I know it must take her lots of time to plan and write the posts for us. Find links to others who are participating in the sidebar of her blog. (There are now 34 of us!) And big thanks to you, dear readers, especially you who leave comments and thoughts.
I'm linking this post to
> Finished (or not) Friday at Alycia Quilts
> Peacock Party at Wendy's Quilts and More
> Can I Get a Whoop Whoop? at Confessions of a Fabric Addict
Thank you for hosting, ladies.
--Nancy.
Nancy, to me this improv QAL is a process, not a style, and if you are likely to make a bed size quilt and you love your big flowers, then just sew them down and enjoy them. You can always make something different with #2 and #3.
ReplyDeleteThose are great points, Anonymous. I decided to keep the flowers but am rearranging them and playing with other elements (container, leaves/or not, etc.). Thanks for the encouragement.
DeleteI love your flowers! I think a lighter green at the base of the flower (where the paper is) could be a nice pop of color. Maybe that could guide your choice in the vase color? (I do like the idea of a vase for them to sit in.) The little tan/white doodads (not sure what else to call them) seem a little much to me, but if you like them, by all means add them. This is your quilt, so while we can tell you what we like, you're the one who has to look at it! (I tell the nieces the same thing when they buy shoes!)
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing your thoughts about my flowers and the other parts of the block, Katie. I'm keeping the flowers, playing around with the other parts (leaves, container, base of flowers, etc.) and the colors.
DeleteI'm sorry Audrey's husband is sick and at the same time grateful for the extra time to get this finished.
I absolutely LOVE the flowers---shape, color, style. I love the little dots. I even love what I thought was to be a bright white vase, a touch of modernism. I vote for cobalt blue tho if you must make it colored. Or horizontal stripes, like blue and white pottery, Cornishware?
ReplyDeleteI was, am, thinking of Improv as a method and process not as a style. And I think for this project you can focus on process...but obviously I know little about this. Maybe Audrey will add some enlightenment or input. For example I don't imagine myself making a Gee's Bend style quilt, much as I admire them--to me they are the epitome of Improv if we are saying it is a style not a method.
lizzy
Thank you, Lizzy. I'm keeping the flowers but rearranging them. I'm still undecided about the vase color. White is too stark for me and blue is a less favorite color, though there are some blues I like (marine, cadet) which I'll audition. I've tried several other colors, too, but haven't found the just-right one yet.
DeleteI think of improv as a method/process, too. When I look up "improv quilts" I see a lot of quilts that look similar--wonky or curved pieces, unusual color combinations, etc., and a definition that said improv was both a style and a method. For this quilt, I'm sticking with the idea of learning a method/process for making a quilt!
I agree with Lizzy. I thought you had chosen white for the vase. I like it. And the big flowers are gorgeous! I especially like the little circle accents. I even like the brown color, it's so subtle. To me, there isn't a usual style of improv. Improv means your didn't use a pattern and are making it up as your go. What you have made certainly qualifies for that. Audition some little pieces of fabric for the base of the flower and see what you like best. It's wonderful, you should pat yourself on the back.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Robin. White is just too stark a color for me so the vase will be some other color. I'm playing around with parts and pieces now, will keep the flowers but rearrange them, will probably keep the little circles, and am still auditioning colors the base of the flower and the vase.
DeleteI like your ideas of what improv means. I think of it that way, too.
I love your big flowers and all the little accents you're considering adding. I'm planning to add a flowerpot to my version, just wasn't able to picture all those stems floating in mid-air. Your paper vase looks good as it is though you might cut a few more vase shapes and see what makes you smile and say "that's it!" And go through all your fabrics for the vase, beyond the ones you've already chosen, you might just find the absolute perfect fabric in a color or pattern you hadn't even considered when we were pulling our fabrics. Anyway, you have a wonderful start with your big bold flowers!
ReplyDeleteThank you, Pat. I appreciate all your suggestions. Yes, I couldn't let the stems float, either. I've cut several more vase shapes and am still auditioning fabric/colors for it and some of the other parts of the block, too. I'm grateful to have extra time to work on this before the next round, though, of course, sorry to hear that Audrey's husband is sick.
DeleteImprov, to me, is what you make and like things to look like--your own ideas. And, I just love your flowers--they look like "you";)));
ReplyDeletethe white vase is wonderful--a real modern look (like Lizzy says)--love it!! I think it is perfect just as is...
Nice work on this--I am sewing mine down as is--no changing around--my chosen idea and will worry about the borders etc as they come...
no over thinking...hugs, Julierose ;)))
Thank you, Julierose. You're good not to overthink your center. It looks great!
DeleteI chuckled when you said my flowers look like me. I'm not so sure. They seem bold and bright and I'm more the behind-the-scenes, wallflower type.
I'm still playing around, auditioning fabrics and colors for various parts of the block. But not a white vase....
Yes to your definition of improv. I like it.
We have to think like Audrey - she puts lots of thought into her quilts but it LOOKS like she didn't. That's improv. I scrolled down to some of your thinking posts and when I saw the pile of possible fabrics there were some blues with small red prints. You mentioned possibly using blue flowers so I'd suggest the vase as a blue/red print. What I like most about Audrey's quilts is the surprise.
ReplyDeleteI believe you're right, Denice, that Audrey puts lots of thought into her quilts. I think they percolate for a while and then she acts, cuts fabric, stitches. And yes, the surprise in her quilts is always fun.
DeleteThanks for the suggestion of one of the blues for the vase. I'm still auditioning fabrics for several parts of the block, including the vase. I'm confident there will be a "perfect" one!
I overthink everything! I kind of think you might know that feeling, LOL.
ReplyDeleteImprov is way out of my comfort zone even though I have done a couple improv sewalongs. I feel one reason improv is so hard for me is that on my sewalongs we were encouraged to just do and not think about it...WHAT?
I love your flowers, and I like the idea of a different green for the piece on the base. The little "doodads" (Thank you Katie, this term is perfect), are an interesting touch, I like them where the white part attaches to the flower then the brown, did you try putting the brown on top of the white? Visualizing is also hard for me so it seems I have to cut out EVERY thought and give it a try. Someday I hope to do a quilt with all those cut out pieces that didn't work for other quilts, there is a lot!
I love Lizzy's idea for the blue and white striped vase but the white does look very modern if you decided on white fabric.
I thought about doing this sewalong but decided I needed to focus on finishing projects I am working on but am totally enjoying watching everyone's progress. Just thinking about it (being improv and unknown steps) made me feel overwhelmed and I chickened out; being a long term project, maybe as I finish a few things I still may join you.
Yes, Joan, I know the feeling of overthinking!
DeleteOh, dear! I've tried just doing without thinking. I wasted time and fabric and ended up frustrated.
Thanks for your comments and thoughts about the flowers. At this point, green is not winning for the base of the flowers. I don't have a green that I think works well. So I'm still auditioning fabrics and colors. The little circles beside the stems and base of the flowers will be only little circles. The white you see are the stickers I used to hold the circles in place. I'm still deciding colors for those, too. The white vase is only the paper I used to imagine size. I didn't want to cut fabric till I had a good idea the size of the vase.
Looking at the flowers, I'm now wondering if I really do need to make some leaves. I was hoping to avoid them.
Oh, yes, visualizing is probably one of the hardest parts of making a quilt for me. I hope you use your cut pieces to make a quilt. I imagine it would be fun and beautiful!
You could join after the second round, then you would know about the center and first border, and by the time you finish that, the next border may have been announced. I find this a very challenging quilt-along. Fun, but challenging.
I love your flowers! For me, the improv part of this QAL is very much about the process, not knowing how it will evolve. Having some comfort in the process is important for me too. I would let it sit and simmer, maybe auditioning fabric for the vase and seeing what options spark joy for you.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Juliann.
DeleteYes, I think process is the important part of the quilt-along. I know some of Audrey's quilts look a little more planned than others, even though they may be improv. I'm one to plan ahead so this is challenging not knowing what's coming next. What a way to learn!
I've been trying out fabrics for the vase, the circles beside the stems, and the shape at the base of the stem. And now I'm thinking I should probably add leaves....
I love your flowers! I think they are an excellent start! I have decided you just have to start throwing things out there. What I mean is cutting out fabric shapes, of different fabric and shapes and sizes, placing them on the background and moving them around. I still don't think I understand the improv style per se. Do you think it is like the primitive style of Cheri Payne, Jan Patek and others?
ReplyDeleteThank you, Rebecca!
DeleteI think your idea of cutting fabric and trying out shapes and sizes, then placing and moving them is a great idea. For someone who can't visualize (like me) it should probably be my method of creating an applique block!
When I look up "improv quilts" on google,
(at this link: https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-1-d&sca_esv=587921074&sxsrf=AM9HkKnc6obGtodY0oRoUzoiPgSsE3Ts4Q:1701753047064&q=improv+quilts&tbm=isch&source=lnms&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiQlfaOxPeCAxVJkokEHVZpD6sQ0pQJegQIDhAB&biw=1440&bih=757&dpr=1)
I find quilts that look like they would be fun to make but quilts that I'm not sure I would enjoy seeing or using every day.
I think of improv as both a method/means of making a quilt (things not planned too far in advance, using fabric we have on hand, choosing next choices in a quilt based on the results of previous choices, improvising as we go) and a style of quilt. For this quilt-along I'm thinking of it as the method/means.
Generally, I don't think of primitive quilts and improv quilts. They may be made by that method but I think primitive is in a separate category. Just my thoughts....
I love your flowers! I would not change a thing! I like the circles by the blooms and the teardrop shape in the green part, too.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Paulette. The parts you mentioned are ones I'm saving. I just have to decide colors for both of them.
DeleteI think the flowers look great!
ReplyDeleteThanks so much, Pat.
DeleteHi Nancy. I love your blousy flowers as well as the doodads. I wouldn’t change them at all. I’m not sure about having a white vase though. I think I would move more in the direction of blue or green. A paisley would look gorgeous.
ReplyDeleteThanks so much, Heather. The vase won't be white! I was trying to decide size using paper instead of cutting fabric. I'm still auditioning fabrics for the vase, the shape at the base of the flower, and the circle. It seems to be looking busy!
DeleteI love your flowers. I don't do applique so its always amazing to me to see what people can do - and yours are amazing!
ReplyDeleteThank you, Alycia. You're so kind. You don't do applique but you make amazing quilts!
DeleteI think the flowers are beautiful--different and unexpected. And I agree with others who have said that improv is the process of making something without a pattern or plan--winging your way through it. :) I make a lot of quilts that way, but never involving applique. LOL Go for it, Nancy. Trust your instincts and make what speaks to you.
ReplyDeleteThank you for your sweet comment and encouraging words, Janet.
DeleteSome of the quilts I make are decide-as-I-go pieces, too. It usually seemed as though I was improvising but my quilts rarely look like the improv quilts I see when I search on that term. I'm pleased to know that others think of improv as the process, not the finished style of a quilt.
I echo everyone's comments that these flowers are lovely and I think too a wonderful improv kind of flower. Yes, to me this works. I have waffled a lot with choosing the final flowers. Improv is a lot harder than it looks -maybe we are way overthinking each choice, Nancy. I think I am.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Jocelyn.
DeleteI may be overthinking my choices but no more than usual, especially if I'm making decisions about a quilt as I make it. Maybe others who don't take a while to make decisions think differently than I do, or have better instincts, or some other ability that I lack....